top of page

Why a Custom Builder Costs More, and Where the Value Goes

17 hours ago
5 min read
Impact Build team on site at a straw bale home under construction in Fryerstown, Victoria.

Let’s start with the honest part. Put a custom builder’s price next to a volume builder’s advertised price and ours will be higher. We’d never pretend otherwise.


But the two numbers aren’t measuring the same thing. A volume builder and a custom builder run completely different operations, and the price reflects that. One is set up for repetition and scale. The other is set up around one family, one site and one home that won’t be built anywhere else.


Volume builders do an important job, and for plenty of people on a flat estate block, a project home is a sensible choice. This isn’t about who’s better. It’s about what’s actually behind the difference, so you can decide what’s right for you and your project.


How volume builders keep the price down


The volume model works because it repeats. The same plans are built again and again, so the engineering is done, the trades know the drill and the materials are bought in bulk.


That advertised base price comes with assumptions, though. It’s usually based on a standard design on a straightforward block, with a standard list of inclusions. Site costs, such as cut and fill, extra footings for reactive soil, retaining and service connections, are generally priced separately once the block has been assessed. Consumer Affairs Victoria also reminds buyers that the display home may not be the standard model, and that changing the standard plan after signing can be expensive. One industry guide suggests allowing 20 to 40 per cent on top of the base price once site costs and typical upgrades are added.


None of this is a criticism. It’s a model built for efficiency, and it does that well. It just isn’t the model we run.


Built to the minimum, or built to last?


Pro Clima airtightness membrane and taped junctions on a wall frame during construction.

Every new home in Australia has to meet the National Construction Code. It’s worth knowing what the code actually is. In its own words, it sets “the minimum required level” for safety, health, amenity, accessibility and sustainability. Since 1 May 2024, that minimum for a new home in Victoria has included a 7-star NatHERS energy rating.


When a business competes on an advertised price, every step above the minimum adds to that number. So in our experience, a lot of base specifications are set to meet the code and not much more. That’s legal and it passes inspection, but it’s the floor.


For us, the code is the starting point, not the goal. That shows up in the parts of a home you’ll never see once it’s finished:


  • Airtightness. Pro Clima membranes and taped junctions go into every project we build, so draughts and moisture are stopped in the wall itself.

  • Insulation and windows chosen for a Macedon Ranges winter, not just for a compliance certificate.

  • Our own quality checks at each key milestone, on top of the building surveyor’s mandatory inspections.

  • Higher-performing products wherever the project allows.


It matters because these are the things you can’t easily come back and fix. Once the walls are lined, the insulation, wrap and framing are there for the life of the house.


A home designed for your site, not repeated on it


Frame of a Woodend home extension positioned to take in the view of Mount Macedon.

Nothing we build is a repeat. Every project starts with the site: where the sun sits in winter, where the wind comes from, how the land falls, what’s in the soil, and what the bushfire or heritage controls require.


That’s not just a design nicety. The federal government’s Your Home guide notes that good orientation can significantly improve comfort and reduce your heating and cooling needs, and that it’s best achieved when you’re building or buying a home. A standard plan placed on a block can’t always take advantage of that. A home designed for that block can.


It’s why our projects look so different from one another. A straw bale home at Fryerstown. An extension at Taradale that reads as though it was always part of the original homestead. A Woodend extension framed around a view of Mount Macedon. Each one was worked out for the people living there and the land it sits on.


A relationship, not a transaction


Impact Build builder walking clients through a home at frame stage.

This is the part that’s hardest to put a price on, and the part our clients talk about most.


With a larger company, it’s common to deal with several different people over the life of a project: a sales consultant at the start, then a contracts or pre-start team, then a site supervisor who is also running a number of other homes.


With us, you’re working with the builder from the first conversation. Before anyone is on site, your project goes through a pre-construction process of more than 100 steps, so the decisions are made on paper, not on the run. Our builder and project manager are across your project every day, testing each other’s assumptions before anything reaches you or a trade. You get clear, regular updates, walk-throughs at the key stages, and decisions and variations in writing.


Some of our favourite projects are with clients who came back to us years later to take the next step. That kind of trust can’t be built from a catalogue.


Fewer surprises along the way


A lower starting number doesn’t always mean a lower finishing number. Consumer Affairs Victoria advises avoiding unspecified prime cost items and provisional sums, which leave the price open, and suggests adding 15 per cent to a detailed estimate for unplanned costs.


We’d rather raise the likely problems before you sign: what the site might throw up, which allowances are soft, and what each one could cost. That way the number you agree to is the number you can plan around. We’ve written more about this in The Real Cost of Choosing the Cheapest Builder.


Where the value shows up over time


The upfront price is paid once. How the home performs, you live with every day.


  • Running costs. Sustainability Victoria says that in most locations, 7-star homes need 20 to 25 per cent less energy than 6-star homes for heating and cooling. Each step up in how the house is built carries through to your power bills for decades.

  • Comfort. A well-sealed, well-insulated home is warmer in July, cooler in January and quieter all year.

  • Maintenance. Quality materials and properly detailed junctions mean fewer callbacks, fewer leaks and fewer things to fix down the track.

  • Resale. A federal government study of detached houses sold in the ACT in 2005 and 2006 found that each extra half-star of energy rating was associated, on average, with a higher sale price: 1.23 per cent in 2005 and 1.91 per cent in 2006. The study’s authors say the exact premium can’t be calculated from it, and it’s one study in one market, but it points the same way as everything else here.


So, is a custom builder worth it?


It depends on what you want from your home. If you want a standard plan on a flat estate block at the lowest entry price, a volume builder may suit you, and that’s a perfectly good choice.


If your site, your brief or your standards don’t fit a catalogue, the extra outlay with a custom builder isn’t a premium for the same thing. It’s a different thing altogether: a home designed for you and your land, built above the minimum, by people who know your project inside out.


The upfront number is what you pay once. How your home performs is what you live with every day.
Verandah of a Taradale homestead extension built by Impact Build, photographed at golden hour.

Thinking about building or renovating?


If you’re planning a new home, renovation or extension in the Macedon Ranges, Hepburn or Mount Alexander regions, start with the Plan Your Build form at impactbd.com.au/plan-your-build, or book a time to chat with Luke.



Luke Said the author of this blog post and founder of Impact Build, smiling and posing for a portrait with his two Border Collies.

About the author


Luke Said is a Master Builder and the founder of Impact Build, a Kyneton-based building company serving the Macedon Ranges, Hepburn and Mount Alexander shires. He directs the business day to day.

bottom of page